Fakes and Forgeries
Wherever genuine antiquities are valued, forgers follow, and objects connected to the Bible are among the most forged in the world. A fake that “proves” a Bible story can sell for a fortune, and believers are sometimes the easiest people to fool, because we want the story to be true.
This page shows three forgeries from our own collection, explains how they were spotted, and tells the stories of some famous cases in biblical archaeology. Our standard in this museum is simple: we do not need to make things up to bolster the Bible. A find is tested before it is taught. The genuine evidence is strong enough on its own.
From our collection
Two small bowls, sold as “dug up at Megiddo”
Two thin, cone-shaped bowls, each about 3½ inches across, with large curved breaks in their rims. The seller said they were dug up at Megiddo.
What gave them away:
- The story. Megiddo is a protected site that has been professionally excavated for more than a century. Objects from it do not end up on a seller’s table with no paperwork.
- The seller’s stock. He had many pots just like these, with similar rim breaks, and buyers did not receive the pot shown in the listing.
- Painted-on “dirt.” The grey film on the outside was brushed on. Where the color changes, the brush strokes can be seen. The inside is clean orange clay.
- Fresh breaks. The broken edges are clean, with none of the soil and mineral deposit that collects on edges buried for thousands of years.
- No signs of burial or use. No root marks, and no wear on the base.
Compare these with the genuine Early Bronze Age bowls in Case One and the red-slipped Iron Age bowl in Case Two.
Black strainer, bought from a New York gallery
A hand-built oval strainer with about thirty holes punched through the floor and two pierced lug handles for hanging. This was one of the first pieces bought for the collection.
What gave it away:
- The finish. A waxy black sheen covers the rim, handles and base, and pale powdery “dirt” sits on top of the sheen in patches, rather than underneath it.
- The source. It came from a Manhattan antiquities gallery. In August 2021, after a four-year investigation by the Manhattan District Attorney, the gallery’s owner was arrested. Investigators found hundreds of fakes on display and thousands more in back rooms, some half-finished, along with tools and putty used to make them look old. In October 2021 he pleaded guilty to forgery and admitted selling thousands of fake antiquities over three decades, aged with paint, chemicals and added dirt.
Strainers like this really were made in the ancient Near East, from the Chalcolithic through the Iron Age. A good forger copies real shapes; the giveaway is in the surface and the source.
How to spot a fake
No single test settles it, but these warning signs show up again and again:
- A story with no paperwork. “Found at a famous site” or “from an old family collection,” with no export permit or excavation record.
- Too many of the same thing. Genuine antiquities are one of a kind. A seller with shelves of near-identical pots is a seller with a workshop.
- Dirt on top, not underneath. Burial deposits form slowly and work into cracks and pores. Paint, wax and dusted-on soil sit on the surface.
- Clean breaks. Ancient breaks collect deposit too. A bright, clean edge usually means a recent break.
- No wear. Real pots were used: bases are scuffed and handles are worn.
- An inscription that is too good to be true. Forgers know what buyers want. An object that names a famous Bible figure, or “proves” a Bible story, deserves the closest look of all.
Famous cases in biblical archaeology
The Shapira scroll (1883)
Moses Shapira, an antiquities dealer in Jerusalem, brought leather strips to Europe that he said came from a cave by the Dead Sea. They held an unusual version of Deuteronomy in ancient Hebrew letters. Scholars in Germany and England declared them fakes, the British scholar Christian Ginsburg in a very public report, and Shapira took his own life the next year. The strips later disappeared. In 2021 Idan Dershowitz argued that they were genuine after all, which has reopened the debate. debated: most scholars still consider them forgeries
The ivory pomegranate
A thumb-sized ivory pomegranate with an inscription reading “(belonging) to the house of [Yahwe]h, holy to the priests.” It was hailed as the only known object from Solomon’s Temple, and the Israel Museum paid $550,000 for it in the late 1980s. In December 2004 the museum announced that the pomegranate itself is ancient, but from the Late Bronze Age, centuries before Solomon, and that the inscription was added in modern times. a few scholars, such as André Lemaire, still defend the inscription
The Jehoash inscription and the James Ossuary
Two sensational finds that surfaced in 2002 from the same collector. The Jehoash inscription is a stone tablet describing repairs to the Temple, like those in 2 Kings 12. The James Ossuary is a genuine first-century bone box inscribed “James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus.” In 2003 committees of the Israel Antiquities Authority declared both inscriptions forgeries, and the collector was charged. After a seven-year trial, the judge acquitted him in March 2012, but he was careful to say the court had not ruled that the inscriptions are genuine, only that forgery had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt. both debated: most scholars consider the Jehoash inscription a forgery; opinion on the ossuary inscription is split
The Museum of the Bible’s “Dead Sea Scrolls”
After 2002, about seventy new “Dead Sea Scroll” fragments appeared on the antiquities market, and some leading scholars accepted them. The Museum of the Bible in Washington, D.C., bought sixteen. When doubts arose, the museum paid for an independent scientific study. In March 2020 the study concluded that all sixteen are modern forgeries: most were written on old leather rather than scroll parchment, coated with a glue-like finish to imitate the sheen of real scrolls, and dusted with Dead Sea minerals. To its credit, the museum published the results and turned its display into an exhibit about the forgeries.
The genuine Dead Sea Scrolls are not in question. They came from the caves near Qumran between 1947 and 1956, found by Bedouin shepherds and by archaeologists, and their sources are well documented. The forgeries are the fragments that turned up on the market after 2002 with no record of where they came from.
Why this matters
Forgeries do real harm. They mislead scholars, cheat buyers, and, when they are exposed, they hand critics a reason to doubt the genuine evidence. The best defense of the Bible’s history is the material that has been excavated, recorded and tested: the Tel Dan Stele, the Siloam Inscription, the Pilate Stone, the Dead Sea Scrolls and many more on our Did You Know? page. Truth does not need help from a forger.
“Test everything; hold fast what is good.” — 1 Thessalonians 5:21